Judge deals blow to Gavin Newsom’s lockdown order in landmark strip-club ruling that could allow EVERY restaurant in San Diego to reopen
- Judge Joel Wohlfeil issued preliminary injunction Wednesday in strip-club case
- Landmark order in Midway Venture vs San Diego has far-reaching implications
- Two strip clubs had sought to remain open despite pandemic restrictions
- Judge agreed that evidence showed risk of viral spread was minimal
- Far-reaching ruling orders all restaurants in San Diego be allowed to open
A judge’s landmark ruling in a strip-club lawsuit could have far reaching implications, allowing all restaurants in San Diego to re-open in a stunning blow to Governor Gavin Newsom’s pandemic lockdown order.
San Diego Superior Court Judge Joel Wohlfeil issued the preliminary injunction on Tuesday, finding that popular strip clubs Pacers and Cheetah’s can re-open – and extending the order to the city’s restaurants.
Pending trial, the order enjoins ‘any government entity or law enforcement officer’ from enforcing Newsom’s shutdown rules against strip clubs, as well as all San Diego restaurants that follow essential protocols to stop the spread of COVID-19.
The order states that the court ‘questions whether there is a rational nexus between the percentage of ICU bed capacity throughout Southern California… and plaintiff’s establishments in San Diego County.’
Pacers is one of the strip-clubs at the center of a lawsuit that has upended California’s lockdown rules, after a judge issued a preliminary injuction allowing it to stay open
The order deals stunning blow to Governor Gavin Newsom’s pandemic lockdown order, after the judge extended it to all ‘San Diego County businesses with restaurant services’
Wohlfiel said it applies to ‘San Diego County businesses with restaurant services,’ including the strip clubs, and that it exempts them from shutdowns and ‘any related orders’ that bar live adult entertainment and go beyond protocols ‘that are no greater than essential’ to controlling the spread of COVID-19.
The judge noted that Pacers International Showgirls and Cheetahs Gentlemen’s Club operated for five weeks during the pandemic under their own safety measures, which included keeping strippers 15 feet from tables, allowing no more than one stripper per stage and requiring them and other employees to wear masks.
San Diego Superior Court Judge Joel Wohlfeil issued the stunning ruling on Wednesday
Michael Workman, a spokesman for San Diego County, said county attorneys were meeting ‘to decipher the ruling and determine what´s next. Stay tuned.’
County supervisors last week vowed to appeal any extension of the exemption for strip clubs, which the judge initially granted last month.
The state attorney general’s office referred questions to Newsom and the California Department of Public Health.
The governor’s office said its legal team was ‘reviewing options to determine next steps.’
‘While we are disappointed in the court’s decision today, we remain steadfast in our commitment to protecting the health and safety of all Californians,’ Newsom’s office said in statement.
Jason Saccuzzo, a lawyer for Pacers, referred to the order’s precise language when asked about its scope, saying it was ‘a difficult question to answer.’
Steve Hoffman, an attorney for Cheetahs, said he was ‘very pleased’ with the ruling and had no comment on whether it extended to other strip clubs and restaurants.
‘Cheetahs and Pacers will continue to operate in a manner that takes all appropriate and essential measures to prevent the spread of COVID-19 while at the same time providing a means for their staff to earn a livelihood,’ he wrote in an email.
The ruling, which takes effect immediately, comes after Newsom’s December 3 stay-at-home order in response to a surge of coronavirus cases that has hammered hospitals across the state.
Cheetahs Gentleman’s Club was also party to the suit. A California judge has extended an order exempting San Diego strip clubs from state pandemic-related restrictions
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra said in a ‘cease-and-desist’ order to both clubs last week that they were violating the state´s new policy, which bars indoor and outdoor dining and prohibits social gatherings that bring together people of different households in an effort to limit the spread of the coronavirus.
Becerra wrote that he was acting on behalf of Newsom, a fellow Democrat, and the state health department and that he will pursue legal action if the companies didn´t comply.
Wednesday’s ruling followed more than an hour of spirited argument about whether state authorities overreached or acted within the law to protect public health.
‘What’s going to happen next when there is some greater emergency? Are we all going to be under house arrest? Are we going to even have a Constitution?’ said Saccuzzo, the Pacers lawyer. ‘I fear that we may end up in a country that we don’t even recognize.’
Patti Li, an attorney for the state, highlighted extreme scarcity of intensive-care unit beds and growing waits in hospital emergency rooms to justify what she emphasized were temporary measures.
‘It really is about the entire community, the entire state,’ Li said. ‘This is the most serious moment of this pandemic in the state, in the nation so far.’
Li disputed the clubs’ argument that orders violated constitutional rights to free speech by prohibiting adult entertainment, saying the restrictions are aimed at live performances with people in close proximity. ‘There is no targeting of expression here,’ she said.
The clubs sued the state and county in October after they were ordered to close.
Last month, a judge in another case denied a request to temporarily lift some restrictions on San Diego County restaurants and gyms.
The California Restaurant Association did not immediately respond to a request for comment on Wednesday’s ruling.